Blog

Show HN for student projects: rules, title and first-comment template

· buildtolaunch

You built something and you want honest feedback from other builders. This guide is for students who are thinking about posting on Hacker News: what Show HN is, whether your project qualifies, how to write the post, and what to do in the hours after. It is one stop on the student launch playbook.

Short answer

Show HN is a section of Hacker News (HN, the tech news and discussion site run by Y Combinator) where people share things they made. Your post title must start with "Show HN", and the project must be something people can try right now, without a sign-up wall. Be ready to answer comments. Never ask friends to upvote. If your project is not ready for strangers, launch it somewhere friendlier first.

What Show HN is, and what it is not

Hacker News is a link and discussion site. Show HN is the part of it meant for your own work. According to the official Show HN rules (as read on 18 Nov 2026), a Show HN submission should be something people can run on their own computer or hold in their hands. You must have built it yourself and be around to talk about it.

Things that do not qualify:

  • Blog posts, newsletters, lists and other reading material (post these as regular submissions, if at all)
  • Sign-up pages, landing pages and fundraisers
  • Work that is not ready for people to try
  • Quickly generated one-offs: the rules say the project should be non-trivial

Two details matter for students who build with AI tools. First, "non-trivial" is a real filter: a weekend app that is a thin wrapper around one prompt may be read as a one-off. Second, the rules say early and unpolished work is fine, as long as people can use it. Explain why you made it and how.

Is your project ready? A 6-point check

Answer yes to all six before you post.

  1. Can a stranger try it in under a minute? The rules do not require it, but they recommend that people can try the project without sign-ups, logins or email gates, because that gets more feedback. A public link that opens straight into the product is best.
  2. Does it work on a phone and a laptop? Test both, because you do not know what device a visitor will use.
  3. Is there a short demo? A 60-second screen recording helps people who will not sign up. See how to record a 60-second app demo (in Vietnamese).
  4. Can you say what it does in one sentence? If not, work on your one-line pitch first.
  5. Have you tried it on real users already? Posting on HN is not the way to find out whether the app works at all. Test it with 5 to 10 people who have the problem first.
  6. Do you have 3 to 4 hours free after posting? The rules expect you to be available to discuss it. A post you cannot answer is a wasted post.

Write the title

The title must begin with "Show HN". Keep the rest plain: the name, then what it does. The general HN guidelines say not to use uppercase, exclamation points or praise in titles. Treat that as a rule for Show HN too.

Formula: Show HN: [Name], [what it does] for [who]

Examples of the pattern (made up for illustration):

  • Show HN: ClassSwap, a free tool for students to swap lab slots
  • Show HN: Grammar checker for Vietnamese that runs in your browser

Weak titles: "Show HN: My amazing new app!!!", "Show HN: I built a startup", "Show HN: Please check out my project".

Write the first comment

A good habit is to add a first comment yourself, right after submitting. The Show HN rules ask you to share why the project matters to you and how you made it, so use that comment for exactly this. Template:

Hi HN, I'm [name], a [major] student in [city]. I built this because [specific problem you had].

What it does: [two sentences].

How I built it: [tools, including AI tools, in plain words, and one thing that was hard].

What I'd like feedback on: [one or two specific questions].

You can try it here without signing up: [link]. Happy to answer anything.

Be honest about how you built it. If an AI tool wrote most of the code, say so and explain what you decided and tested yourself. Readers respect that more than a vague claim.

After you post

  1. Stay in the thread. Reply to every comment, including the harsh ones, politely. The HN guidelines say comments should be curious, not combative, and the Show HN page asks you to avoid gratuitous negativity.
  2. Do not ask for upvotes. The Show HN rules say not to ask friends to upvote or comment, and the guidelines say the same about solicitation. Asking can get a post penalised. Share your link in other places if you like, but never write "please upvote".
  3. Do not delete and repost. The guidelines say deletion is for submissions that should not have been posted, and the FAQ says reposts of the same story are generally buried as duplicates unless it is a small number of reposts of something that has had little attention.
  4. Take notes. Copy useful feedback into a list. Fix the top issue the same day and say so in the thread.
  5. Expect little. A post can get few comments or none. The FAQ says ranking depends on many factors beyond points and time, so a quiet post is not proof that your project is bad.

Where to post first

If you have zero audience, Show HN is a high-pressure first stop. Readers there are strangers, and feedback can be blunt. A better order:

  1. Send your link to 10 people who have the problem.
  2. Post a launch on a friendly board, such as the Launch League, where other student builders try new projects.
  3. Fix the biggest issues.
  4. Then try Show HN, Product Hunt or other public sites once you have a few real users and a short demo.

For a comparison of the options, see Launch League vs Product Hunt vs Peerlist, and which launch sites are still free in 2026.

Practising on buildtolaunch

buildtolaunch is a free community for university students in Vietnam and Southeast Asia, any major, no coding needed to start. The Launch League is a public board where members post what they launched; it resets every Monday, so you can practise writing a launch post, a one-line pitch and a demo every week before you face a bigger audience. Members also build in project Spaces with an AI teammate, and the courses library has 70+ free courses to help you build something worth posting. Sign up here if you want to start.

FAQ

Can students post on Show HN?

Yes. The rules do not ask who you are. They ask that the project is yours, that people can try it, and that you can discuss it. A student project is welcome as long as it is real and non-trivial.

Does my project need a sign-up?

No. The rules say there is no sign-up requirement, but they recommend letting people try the project without sign-ups or logins, since that gets more feedback. If your app needs an account, add a demo mode, a test login in your first comment, or a video.

Can I use AI tools to build a Show HN project?

Nothing in the Show HN rules bans AI-assisted code, but the rules exclude quickly generated one-offs and require that you built the project and can discuss it. Be ready to explain the decisions you made, what you tested and what the AI got wrong. Write the post and comments yourself.

Is a landing page or waitlist a Show HN?

No. The rules list landing pages and sign-up pages as things that do not qualify. If you only have a landing page, use another site for early feedback, and post on Show HN when there is a working product.

What if nobody comments?

It can happen and does not mean the project failed. Ranking depends on more than votes, and timing is partly luck. Send the link to people who have the problem, ask for one piece of feedback each, and try again later with a real update rather than reposting the same thing.

Should I ask friends to upvote?

No. The Show HN page and the HN guidelines both say not to solicit upvotes or comments. Ask friends for honest feedback instead, in a private message, and let them decide whether to post anywhere.

Ready to plan the rest of your launch? Read the full guide.